I was interviewed by the the popular science site videnskab.dk on using iPad apps in research an education (in Danish).
Friday, March 9, 2012
Apps can make you smarter
I was interviewed by the the popular science site videnskab.dk on using iPad apps in research an education (in Danish).
Tuesday, February 28, 2012
Here are my funded grant proposals
I recently came across this interesting blog post by mathematician Doron Zeilberger entitled Opinion 117: People Should Learn to Share their Ideas, and Make their Funded Grant Proposals Public (and an Efficient Algorithm for convincing those that refuse).
There he writes:
Mathematics and Science is a communal enterprise, and it is very important that people share their ideas. Unfortunately, it is very hard to get the big picture. The number of good expository articles is, unfortunately, very small. (People who write them should be rewarded! A good expository article is worth one thousand mediocre (and even good) technical papers.)
People are at their expository best when they are begging for money, and in the case of mathematicians and scientists, this means writing a grant proposal. The scientific community would benefit a lot if people would publicly post their funded grants, and be generous with their ideas.
The man is right. So, without further ado*, here are my (i.e. where I was PI) funded proposals:**
2010 Protein Design Using Quantum Mechanics (Danish Center for Supercomputing)
2010 Protein Design Using Quantum Mechanics (Danish Center for Supercomputing)
2008 Computational Design of Stable Enzymes (Danish National Science Foundation, DSF-NABIIT)
2006 Modeling pH-Dependence in Drug Design (EU Marie Curie Program)
2006 Modeling pH-Dependence in Drug Design (EU Marie Curie Program)
2006 Computational Prediction and Validation of Protein Structure and Function in Protein Engineering and Rational Drug Design (Danish National Science Foundation, FNU)
2006 Prediction and Interpretation of Protein pKa’s Using QM/MM (US National Science Foundation - MCB; rescinded when I moved to Denmark)
2006 Prediction and Interpretation of Protein pKa’s Using QM/MM (US National Science Foundation - MCB; rescinded when I moved to Denmark)
2002 The Prediction and Interpretation of Protein pKa’s Using QM/MM (US National Science Foundation - MCB)
* Actually, just a bit more ado: This seems like a good occasion to publicly thank Lou Messerle at the University of Iowa. Whatever success I have had in getting proposals funded is a direct result of Lou's fantastic help with the 2002 NSF proposal.
** That still open correctly in Word
Monday, February 27, 2012
If I deposit a pre-print on arXiv or Nature Precedings where can I submit my paper?
When we submitted our last paper for publication, we also posted the manuscript on the pre-print server arXiv. This has several advantages:
(1) It makes the work freely accessible to everyone while the paper is being reviewed
(2) It makes the work freely accessible to everyone after its been published
(3) It establishes priority
However, journals will not accept manuscripts that have already been published. Will depositing a paper on a preprint server like arXiv.org or Nature Precedings prevent me from submitting my paper to a journal?
That depends on the journal, and you can check using this site call SHERPA/RoMEO.
PLoS ONE
Our paper went PLoS ONE. Not surprisingly, SHERPA/RoMEO tells you that PLoS ONE is a "green journal" that allows you to pretty much to anything with your manuscript before and after it is published. This makes sense since PLoS ONE is an open access journal.
Journal of Physical Chemistry A and Journal of Chemical Theory and Computations
But what if the paper doesn't get into PLoS ONE for some reason? In my pre-OA days I probably would have sent this paper to JPC-A or JCTC. SHERPA/RoMEO tells me both are "white journals" meaning I have to get permission from the publisher first, before I submit my pre-print.
I wasn't sure exactly what that meant so I wrote the managing editor of both journals, which happens to be the same person, whether I could submit to JPC-A and JCTC if I had deposited my manuscript in arXiv of Nature Precedings. The answer is "yes" for JPC-A (and B, C, and Letters) in both cases, and in the case of JCTC: "yes" for arXiv and "undecided" for Nature Precedings.
In all cases you have to state in the cover letter where you have posted your preprint.
Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics
SHERPA/RoMEO lists PCCP as a "blue journal" meaning pre-print deposition is not allowed. However, the RSC License to Publish clearly states that deposition in arxiv is OK. So I contacted them. Deposition in ArXiv is allowed, but deposition in Nature Precedings is not!
Updates:The following journals will also consider manuscripts submitted to arXiv:
Update (2013.01.06): All American Physical Society journals including Physical Review and Physical Review Letters (HT +Robert Garisto)
Update (2013.01.06): Journal of Molecular Modeling and Nature Chemistry (HT +Grant Hill for info)
Update (2012.08.29): Journal of Chemical Information and Modeling
Lessons Learned
(1) If you want to deposit your pre-print prior to submission, check SHERPA/RoMEO. If in doubt, check with the journal. But be patient, getting an answer can take a while.
(2) Even non-profit society journals (and their editors!) have their own interests in mind, not yours or science in general.
(3) Rational thinking doesn't seem to apply here in general. Why would arXiv be OK, but not Nature Precedings?
(1) It makes the work freely accessible to everyone while the paper is being reviewed
(2) It makes the work freely accessible to everyone after its been published
(3) It establishes priority
However, journals will not accept manuscripts that have already been published. Will depositing a paper on a preprint server like arXiv.org or Nature Precedings prevent me from submitting my paper to a journal?
That depends on the journal, and you can check using this site call SHERPA/RoMEO.
PLoS ONE
Our paper went PLoS ONE. Not surprisingly, SHERPA/RoMEO tells you that PLoS ONE is a "green journal" that allows you to pretty much to anything with your manuscript before and after it is published. This makes sense since PLoS ONE is an open access journal.
Journal of Physical Chemistry A and Journal of Chemical Theory and Computations
But what if the paper doesn't get into PLoS ONE for some reason? In my pre-OA days I probably would have sent this paper to JPC-A or JCTC. SHERPA/RoMEO tells me both are "white journals" meaning I have to get permission from the publisher first, before I submit my pre-print.
I wasn't sure exactly what that meant so I wrote the managing editor of both journals, which happens to be the same person, whether I could submit to JPC-A and JCTC if I had deposited my manuscript in arXiv of Nature Precedings. The answer is "yes" for JPC-A (and B, C, and Letters) in both cases, and in the case of JCTC: "yes" for arXiv and "undecided" for Nature Precedings.
In all cases you have to state in the cover letter where you have posted your preprint.
Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics
SHERPA/RoMEO lists PCCP as a "blue journal" meaning pre-print deposition is not allowed. However, the RSC License to Publish clearly states that deposition in arxiv is OK. So I contacted them. Deposition in ArXiv is allowed, but deposition in Nature Precedings is not!
Updates:The following journals will also consider manuscripts submitted to arXiv:
Update (2013.01.06): All American Physical Society journals including Physical Review and Physical Review Letters (HT +Robert Garisto)
Update (2013.01.06): Journal of Molecular Modeling and Nature Chemistry (HT +Grant Hill for info)
Update (2012.08.29): Journal of Chemical Information and Modeling
Lessons Learned
(1) If you want to deposit your pre-print prior to submission, check SHERPA/RoMEO. If in doubt, check with the journal. But be patient, getting an answer can take a while.
(2) Even non-profit society journals (and their editors!) have their own interests in mind, not yours or science in general.
(3) Rational thinking doesn't seem to apply here in general. Why would arXiv be OK, but not Nature Precedings?
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.
Dear Elsevier
David C. Clary
Editor
Chemical Physics Letters
Dear Prof. Clary
Thank you for the invitation to review for Chemical Physics Letters.
I no longer publish or review in Elsevier journals. My reasons are summarized on http://thecostofknowledge.com/
With best regards,
Jan Jensen
Editor
Chemical Physics Letters
Dear Prof. Clary
Thank you for the invitation to review for Chemical Physics Letters.
I no longer publish or review in Elsevier journals. My reasons are summarized on http://thecostofknowledge.com/
With best regards,
Jan Jensen
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.
Sunday, February 26, 2012
The PROPKA proposal
It's hard to write a proposal, and I had made several false starts. To get out of the rut I used a trick I've used before where I make a sort of outline/very condensed version where I focus exclusively on what I want to say rather than how I want to say it.
Anyway, the trick worked once again, and the proposal was shipped off on Friday - three days before the deadline. Only this time I wrote the document on blogger and, inspired by Rosie Redfields latest post, I am putting it up on the blog.
Title: Electrostatics in Protein/Nucleic Acid Complexes
Not a very sexy title, but what else?
Objective
Extend PROPKA to DNA and RNA and use it to ...?
Background and Significance
pKa Prediction. Proteins contains charged groups that are key to their stability and function. Assigning correct charges is crucial for rationalizing and modeling protein chemistry. It is hard to measure these charges, so they have to be computed. PROPKA is arguably the most popular way of doing this: many users and citations, interface to popular programs such as PDB2PQR and VMD.
Thanks to these efforts protein charges can now be assigned with confidence. However, picture is different for the other major biomolecules DNA and RNA, and protein-DNA/RNA complexes.
Most pKa prediction programs can only handle proteins. PROPKA is one of the few programs that have been extended to small molecule ligands. No pKa prediction program has been extended to DNA and RNA (check if that's true?), and this is what is proposed here.
Protein-DNA/RNA complexes. Why are proteins-DNA/RNA complexes important? Why are charged groups important for these complexes? What complexes will PROPKA be applied to and why these?
Who are involved? Jan, Mats, PNNL, UIUC,
Research Plan and Methodology
How will PROPKA be modified to handle DNA and RNA? pKmodel values, hydrogen bond strengths,
How will it be validated? What experimental data is there? Compute pKa values using EFMO.
What systems will it be applied to? What will be computed?
Anyway, the trick worked once again, and the proposal was shipped off on Friday - three days before the deadline. Only this time I wrote the document on blogger and, inspired by Rosie Redfields latest post, I am putting it up on the blog.
Title: Electrostatics in Protein/Nucleic Acid Complexes
Not a very sexy title, but what else?
Objective
Extend PROPKA to DNA and RNA and use it to ...?
Background and Significance
pKa Prediction. Proteins contains charged groups that are key to their stability and function. Assigning correct charges is crucial for rationalizing and modeling protein chemistry. It is hard to measure these charges, so they have to be computed. PROPKA is arguably the most popular way of doing this: many users and citations, interface to popular programs such as PDB2PQR and VMD.
Thanks to these efforts protein charges can now be assigned with confidence. However, picture is different for the other major biomolecules DNA and RNA, and protein-DNA/RNA complexes.
Most pKa prediction programs can only handle proteins. PROPKA is one of the few programs that have been extended to small molecule ligands. No pKa prediction program has been extended to DNA and RNA (check if that's true?), and this is what is proposed here.
Protein-DNA/RNA complexes. Why are proteins-DNA/RNA complexes important? Why are charged groups important for these complexes? What complexes will PROPKA be applied to and why these?
Who are involved? Jan, Mats, PNNL, UIUC,
Research Plan and Methodology
How will PROPKA be modified to handle DNA and RNA? pKmodel values, hydrogen bond strengths,
How will it be validated? What experimental data is there? Compute pKa values using EFMO.
What systems will it be applied to? What will be computed?
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.
Thursday, February 23, 2012
Computational Chemistry Highlights: A new kind of chemistry journal
What is Computational Chemistry Highlights?
CCH is an overlay journal that identifies the most important papers in computational and theoretical chemistry published in the last 1-2 years. CCH is not affiliated with any publisher: it is a free resource run by scientists for scientists.
What is an overlay journal?
An overlay journal is simply a journal that collects manuscript from other sites. For example, Faculty of 1000 is a relatively well known overlay journal, though it doesn't call itself that, that has been around since 2002. However, there are some key differences between F1000.com and CCH:
* CCH is free of charge
* CCH accepts comments on entries (for example other reviews)
* CCH accepts suggestions, including preprints deposited on preprint servers like arxiv.org
The last point means that you can choose to submit your next paper for publication in CCH. It is peer reviewed after all; in fact the review is also published if the paper is accepted.
You retain all the rights to your work. You can even submit a CCH paper to a conventional journal if you wish (and that journal agrees to consider it - check first). However, your paper is only reviewed if it is accepted and CCH only accepts the most important recent papers in the field (think of it as very aggressive triage).
One possible future of scientific publishing
One could imagine a future where the publication process consists of depositing your preprint on a public server such as arxiv.org and then simultaneously submitting the paper to several overlay journals, such as CCH, with various levels of prestige. These journals, in turn, act as feeders to even more prestigious overlay journals (a la Science and Nature) which select their most important contributions of general interest.
A paper could be published in increasingly more journals as its importance becomes established. It's a fairer and more open way of identifying important papers that does not slow the dissemination of scientific results.
Will it ever be this way?
Will it ever be this way? Will CCH become widely read and regarded? I don't know - time will tell. What I can tell you is that anyone can set up a site like this and we decide whether it works or not.
The ball is in our court now. Are you game?
CCH is an overlay journal that identifies the most important papers in computational and theoretical chemistry published in the last 1-2 years. CCH is not affiliated with any publisher: it is a free resource run by scientists for scientists.
What is an overlay journal?
An overlay journal is simply a journal that collects manuscript from other sites. For example, Faculty of 1000 is a relatively well known overlay journal, though it doesn't call itself that, that has been around since 2002. However, there are some key differences between F1000.com and CCH:
* CCH is free of charge
* CCH accepts comments on entries (for example other reviews)
* CCH accepts suggestions, including preprints deposited on preprint servers like arxiv.org
The last point means that you can choose to submit your next paper for publication in CCH. It is peer reviewed after all; in fact the review is also published if the paper is accepted.
You retain all the rights to your work. You can even submit a CCH paper to a conventional journal if you wish (and that journal agrees to consider it - check first). However, your paper is only reviewed if it is accepted and CCH only accepts the most important recent papers in the field (think of it as very aggressive triage).
One possible future of scientific publishing
One could imagine a future where the publication process consists of depositing your preprint on a public server such as arxiv.org and then simultaneously submitting the paper to several overlay journals, such as CCH, with various levels of prestige. These journals, in turn, act as feeders to even more prestigious overlay journals (a la Science and Nature) which select their most important contributions of general interest.
A paper could be published in increasingly more journals as its importance becomes established. It's a fairer and more open way of identifying important papers that does not slow the dissemination of scientific results.
Will it ever be this way?
Will it ever be this way? Will CCH become widely read and regarded? I don't know - time will tell. What I can tell you is that anyone can set up a site like this and we decide whether it works or not.
The ball is in our court now. Are you game?
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)